The Best Way to Reheat Deep Dish Pizza-The Complete Guide

The Best Way to Reheat Deep Dish Pizza-The Complete Guide

Pizza is one of the most favorite fast foods for almost all of us. Any party, get together, meeting or discussion remain incomplete without pizza.

Whenever you are making a get together or a late-night or all-night party with your gang, pizza is a must to entertain your tummy. Even when comes the question of online ordering, we first think about pizza.

You can even store your leftover pizza slices and eat them again whenever you want. But for that, you must learn how to store and reheat your pizza, especially the deep dish pizza.

So, at the end of the article, we will show some ways to do it properly.

How to Reheat Pizza?

Whenever you would go to reheat or warm up your slices, you must learn it before—reheating pizza demands to follow some particular instructions. Because there are both positive and negative sides of warmed up or reheated pizza, and it is far better to have no pizza rather than to meet the negative sides of reheating.

Moreover, if you are the person who has the experience of eating a sloppy pizza ever, you can best relate then. As your pizza slices are already meshed up, so you need to be extra careful while reheating them.

Here go some ways on how to reheat or warm up your pizza properly.

  • Reheat Pizza Using an Oven
  • Reheat With A Toaster Oven
  • Reheat With A Skillet

Preparing and Storing Pizza for Reheating

If you decide to store your pizza for tomorrow, you need to know how to store and prepare for reheating. It is very important. You should store your pizza as early as possible. Otherwise, your pizza might get infected with bacteria.

The best way of storing your pizza is to get the pizza out of the box. Then you can cover up or wrap up either with a plastic or an aluminum foil. You can also put your pizza slices in a zip lock bag.

The Best Way to Reheat Deep Dish Pizza-The Complete Guide

Any of the above paths, you can follow whatever you like. Your main focus will be to protect your pizza until it gets reheated. Then before reheating your pizza, uncover them and set them according to the demand of your reheating tool.

You will learn some general tricks and tips for reheating your pizza here.

Do not use a Microwave:

First of all, you have to remember that you should never reheat your pizza in a microwave oven because a leftover pizza carries a small number of sloppy silts typically in it.

Reheating or warming up your pizza in a microwave oven enhances the amount of these soppy silts. As a result, the leftover pizza gets too much soggy and moist to eat.

Use a Toaster Instead

This microwave reheating issue is mostly faced by the students who live in hostels or quarters. In the hostels or quarters, there are microwave ovens in students' rooms or the dining room.

There are no other options for them than this microwave oven to warm up their pizzas. In this case, if you are a victim too, you can use a toaster instead. You can buy it for your benefits.

Toaster ovens are very much inexpensive. You can set it easily in one corner of your room because it does not take so many spaces. Therefore, the toaster oven offers a traditional, healthy, and well economic food warming. It has remained popular for its advantages from the very beginning, even before the invention of a microwave oven.

So, you can use a toaster oven for reheating your pizza without any doubt. If you are the one who lives outside dorms and in your own house, it is easier for you to use an oven then.

Use an Oven For Chicago Style Pizza

Talking about Chicago style pizza, the oven is the best way to reheat your pizza then. You will never get the perfect taste of Chicago style pizza if you reheat it in the microwave oven.

The oven will help you to get your ultimate and original taste out of it. So you must know how to reheat pizza in the oven.

How to Reheat Pizza in Oven

The oven is the best way to reheat your pizza. And it is already mentioned that there are positive and negative sides of reheating a leftover pizza. So, to do it properly, you must learn how to reheat pizza in the oven at the very first hand.

Both normal oven and toaster oven are helpful for you to get your perfect taste. So, here are the essential instructions for you to learn the best way to reheat pizza in the oven.

The Best Way to Reheat Pizza in Oven  in 6 Steps

  • Firstly, you must set your oven in 350-450 degrees Fahrenheit temperature for preheating. It is a "must-do" task for you.
  • Secondly, you have to cover up the cooking sheet of your oven using a foil paper. The foil paper must be made of aluminum. Then, for a better result, you need to sprinkle a little amount of cooking spray over the foil-wrapped sheet.
  • Thirdly, you have to place your pizza slices on the cooking sheet. But in that case, you should be careful about keeping some spaces between the slices.
  • Fourthly, in order to give your pizza slices a moisture-boosting, you need to spray water on them. Remember, spray water in a very little amount.
  • Fifthly, in this step, you have to unwrap your pizza again with a foil paper made of aluminum. But you must cover this up a bit loosely.
  • Finally, wait until your pizza gets reheated perfectly. Set the temperature for reheating as you want it. At least wait for 10-15 minutes to warm your pizza up with complete perfection.

The Best Way to Reheat Pizza in Toaster Oven

You already know that a toaster oven is the best way to reheat pizza for those who live in hostels or dorms. It is more effective and easy to use. If you want to reheat your Chicago style pizza or deep-dish pizza, then it is the best choice.

The Best Way to Reheat Deep Dish Pizza-The Complete Guide

In order to reheat your pizza in a toaster oven, you should maintain the following rules. The rules are almost similar to the oven, which has been mentioned above. Still, for your help and the little differences a toaster oven possesses, the rules are discussed below:


Just like an oven, you need to do the same preheating task. It is a crucial step to follow. You must preheat your toaster oven, not more than to 450 degrees Fahrenheit. If you do not preheat the toaster, your pizza might get burnt.


Now, wrap up your cooking sheet of the toaster oven with a foil paper. Again, similar to the oven, you have to use the aluminum foil paper for oven baking. They are safe for health too. If you do not use it, your food might get stuck with the cooking pot after reheating.


After that, you need to sprinkle some cooking spray over the wrapping foil. Place the deep dish pizza into the cooking sheet. You should place them on the upper or top part of the cooking sheet. Ensure that there are some gaps among your pizza slices.


Further, spray a little amount of water on the slices. The water helps to give the pizza a boost up with moisture. Unlike other pizza, you want your deep-dish pizza to enhance its inside water so that your pizza can get a perfect structure just like it was when you bought it.

However, do not use much water because your pizza might get soggy or too hard. Use as much water as your pizza needs. You must be very careful about the amount of water, remember.


Now wrap up your pizza using another foil paper. This paper will help your pizza to fight with moisture and also will save it from burning. Finally, it's time to let your pizza into the toaster oven for baking and reheating.

You have to bake it for a maximum of 20 to 30 minutes. But keep in mind that you must check it out every five minutes. It will prevent your pizza from burning, and you will get your perfect taste as well.

The Best Way to Reheat Pizza in the Skillet

Using a skillet to reheat your pizza is also very easy. In case you do not have an oven or toaster oven near to you, you can use the skillet easily to get your reheated pizza.

You don't need any special tricks or tips to use it. Just give a read to the following steps once, you will easily understand the whole process.

  • First of all, place your skillet on a burner and make it on. You have to keep your burner at medium-high heat, not more than that.
  • Smear your pan very smoothly with olive oil. Make sure that the olive oil layer is very light on the pan.
  • Now cover up your pan and let it heat for some time.
  • After your pan is heated a bit, you can place your pizza slices on the pan.
  • You must be very much careful about the heat of your burner. At this point, you have to low down the heat from medium-high to medium heat.
  • Finally, let your pizza cook on the pan for a maximum 3 to 6 minutes.

Your pizza is ready to eat now. So, enjoy your pizza reheated with the skillet.

Secret Reheating Tricks for Your Deep Dish Pizza

The ways and tricks that are provided above will surely work for perfectly reheating your pizza. But if you are a deep-dish pizza lover, you should follow some special tricks then. Chicago style deep dish pizza differs from all other pizza because of its cooking specialty.

The Best Way to Reheat Deep Dish Pizza-The Complete Guide

You can use both an oven or a skillet to reheat your deep dish pizza. You will find the secret reheating tricks for your deep dish pizza using both ways. You can use whatever you like or available to you. So let's start with the skillet.

Using A Skillet

Just like its name, deep-dish pizza possesses huge amounts of ingredients in it. It is normally cooked or made in a pan. So for reheating, it should come back to a pan again. And skillet is the best potion for this.

Let's learn how to reheat your deep dish pizza perfectly in a skillet.

  • Take your skillet and set in on the burner. Do not say act that you don't have a skillet. You are a deep-dish pizza lover and adult enough to have a skillet.
  • Put the temperature or heat of the burner at medium-high.
  • Brush up your pan with a little amount of olive oil. Be careful about using oil because excessive oil might make your pizza greasy and more oily.
  • Once the pan gets heated, place your deep-dish pizza on the pan. In this period, you have to low down the heat of the burner. You should turn it into medium heat from medium-high temperature.
  • After that, cover up your pan with a lid. It is mandatory. It helps your pizza toppings to become also warmed and adequately your cheeses to meltdown. Moisture balance is another important issue while reheating your pizza. Covering the pan also provides you this advantage.
  • Wait for at least three to five minutes until your pizza gets completely cooked or reheated.
  • Now, after three to five minutes, your leftover pizza is ready to enjoy.

Using an Oven

You can also use your oven to warm up your favorite deep dish pizza. It is also effortless to do. Just go through the instructions given below. You will learn the process step by step.

  • The first thing you need to do is to preheat your oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit temperature. This temperature is best for Chicago style pizza, especially the deep dish one. It might take a little bit of time. But you can be sure of not getting your pizza burnt.
  • Now place your pizza slices on the cooking sheet of the oven. Make sure that your cooking sheet is perfectly sprinkled with cooking spray and oil. Cooking oil and spray must be of good measure, not so less or excessive.
  • After that, place your leftover pizza slices on the upper side of the cooking sheet. You should spray a little amount of water so that the cheeses of your slices can get a moisture-boosting.
  • Put your cooking tray with the pizza into the oven and set your desired temperature. The important fact you need to care about is to use an aluminum foil paper. You have to cover up your pizza slices with this foil paper. This foil paper will help your pizza not to be burnt if the temperature is high by chance.
  • Wait for the pizza to get warmed perfectly. After it has been warmed according to your desire, get your pizza out of the oven. Let it leave to cool for some time.
  • Finally, your reheated deep dish pizza is ready to serve and enjoy.

Basically, reheating pizza is not a very hard task to do. You just need to know the right way to do it perfectly. Deep dish pizza usually is different from others. It contains heavy cheese and sauces.

So there is a slight difference in its reheating process. But it is also very simple as the traditional pizza reheating. You have to be a bit careful about the temperature and time.

If you can warm up or reheat your pizza perfectly, you will enjoy the ultimate taste. But if you follow the wrong paths, you might not get your desired taste.

What About Pizza Stones?

Pizza stones usually are like plates on which you place your leftover pizza slices for reheating in the oven. However, they are a bit expensive. Secondly, they are available in a shape that does not match in other places except an oven.

The Best Way to Reheat Deep Dish Pizza-The Complete Guide

Even it will not fit in a toaster oven, but very good news for you that you need not use any pizza stones while following any above ways. You can quickly reheat your pizza without a pizza stone.

But if you already have any pizza stone, you must learn how to use and handle it properly. Otherwise, it might cause harm to you as well as your food too.


  • Never use a microwave for reheating your pizza. It can make your leftover pizza slices very soggy.
  • Store your pizza as early as possible. Otherwise, your food will get affected by bacteria.


Now you know the best way to reheat your deep dish pizza properly. You have the complete guide of all the methods and options of reheating your pizza. Pick any way you like and warm up your pizza perfectly.

So, following these instructions, reheat your pizza and enjoy the perfect taste. Your food maintains your health. So, be careful always.


How to Reheat Frozen Pizza?

Reheat your frozen pizza with a cast iron pan and an oven. Put the frozen pizza into the oven for some time to defrost. Then, brush some olive oil on the iron pan and set the pan on the burner. Place your pizza on the pan and reheat it with medium heat. You can even reheat it in the oven using 350 degrees Fahrenheit temperature.

Can You Put a Pizza Box in the Oven?

Generally, it is wise not to put your pizza box in the oven. But if you have a cardboard pizza box, you can put it in the oven. In that case, you must be careful about the temperature. The cardboard starts to burn at 450 degrees Fahrenheit. So make sure you set your temperature lower than that.

How long can you leave pizza out?

You can leave your pizza out for a maximum of two hours. It has experimented that if your pizza is left out for more than two hours, you should not eat it. It becomes injurious to your health then.

How long does leftover pizza last?

Your leftover pizza can last safely for at least four days in the refrigerator. But you have to put it in the fridge within two hours of leaving it. After four days, bacteria start to infect your food.

What is deep-dish pizza?

Deep dish pizza is the most popular form of Chicago style pizza. It contains a huge amount of cheeses and stocky tomato sauces.